Skip to content

The Cookie Lady: Mrs Drew and Bubber | ISC Class 12

questionbuddy.in/isc/class-12/english-literature/the-cookie-lady/mrs-drews-fascination-with-bubber-and-the-role-of-the-cookies

English LiteratureISC Class 12 · The Cookie Lady

The Cookie Lady: Mrs Drew's Fascination with Bubber and the Role of the Cookies (ISC Class 12)

Updated 18 October 2026 · Fact-checked

Mrs Drew draws on Bubber's youth to grow younger. The cookies are the bait that brings him back, the request to be read to is the pretext that keeps him close, and the request to touch his arm is the means by which she draws his vitality. When Bubber says it will be his last visit she is stunned, because without him she would grow old and wrinkled again.

Notice the chain: cookies bring Bubber, reading keeps him close, touch draws his youth, so his last visit stuns her because she would grow old again.

Illustration drawn for QuestionBuddy.

Understand The Cookie Lady: Mrs Drew's Fascination with Bubber and the Role of the Cookies

Why this topic matters. The Cookie Lady was set in both 2025 papers: the specimen asked about Mrs Drew's fascination with Bubber, covering her repeated interactions and the role of the cookies, and the 2025 board paper asked why she is stunned when Bubber says it will be his last visit. The story is in copyright, so this page paraphrases the chapter page, which takes its facts from the CISCE 2025 specimen key and marking scheme. Collect your own short quotations from Prism.

1. Bubber's visits. Bubber is a young boy who goes again and again to the house of an old woman, Mrs Drew. She welcomes him with cookies, and the treats are what bring him back.

2. The reading. She asks him to read to her from his books, explaining that she does not see well any more and that it is a comfort to be read to. The specimen treats this request as the reason for the next: it keeps the boy sitting close to her.

3. The touch. As he reads, she asks whether he minds if she touches his arm. According to the specimen key she drew from his vitality and enjoyed the transformation she experienced; she was growing younger again by stealing his youth.

4. The three devices. The cookies are the bait that bring the boy; the reading is the pretext that keeps him beside her; the touch is the means by which she draws his energy.

5. The last visit. When Bubber tells her that this will be his last visit, she is stunned. The marking scheme explains: without him she would lose the opportunity to renew her youth, and in his absence she would grow old and wrinkled again. Her dismay is not a lonely woman's sadness at losing a friend but the alarm of someone losing her source of life.

6. Themes. Appearance and reality (a cosy surface and a sinister purpose); exploitation of the young by the old (he gains treats, she gains life); fear of ageing and the longing for youth; temptation and innocence (a child drawn in by small treats and politeness).

7. Writing a 5-mark answer (100-150 words). Mrs Drew's repeated interactions with Bubber (2), the role of the cookies (1.5), the link to her purpose (1), expression (0.5).

The Cookie Lady: Mrs Drew's Fascination with Bubber and the Role of the Cookies: key facts

Three devices
Cookiesbait
Readingpretext
Touchmeans
Use as the spine of an answer.
Appearance and reality
Kind, weak-sighted old lady | Draws his youth to grow younger
Core contrast.
Why stunned
  • Last visit
  • Loses source of youth
  • Would grow old and wrinkled
Dependence, not friendship.

How to answer The Cookie Lady: Mrs Drew's Fascination with Bubber and the Role of the Cookies questions

Use this plan for a question on Mrs Drew and Bubber.

  1. 1Open with the surface: an old lady who bakes for a boy.
  2. 2Show the three devices: cookies, reading, touch.
  3. 3Reveal the purpose: drawing his youth.
  4. 4For 'last visit', explain her dependence and fear of ageing.
  5. 5End with the theme of appearance and reality or exploitation.

The Cookie Lady: Mrs Drew's Fascination with Bubber and the Role of the Cookies in real life

The idea, met in an everyday situation. Answer the question in your own words, then compare with the model answer. The one-line hook is what to remember.

Treats that hide a motive

Suppose a stranger on the street offers a child free sweets every afternoon and soon asks him to carry shopping bags for 'just one more favour'.

How does this resemble Mrs Drew's use of cookies, and what lesson does it carry?

Try it first, then show the solutionSolution
  1. Treats are bait that bring the child back.
  2. Small favours keep him close until the real purpose is served.

Answer: Like the cookies, the sweets are bait; children should be wary of kindness that has hidden purposes.

Memory hook: Free treats may have a price.

Tricks to remember The Cookie Lady: Mrs Drew's Fascination with Bubber and the Role of the Cookies

Short memory aids. Say each one aloud once, then use it on a question the same day.

  • B-P-M

    Bait (cookies), Pretext (reading), Means (touch).

    Use it when: Mrs Drew's devices.

  • Sweet outside, sinister inside

    A cosy surface hides her motive.

    Use it when: Appearance and reality.

The Cookie Lady: Mrs Drew's Fascination with Bubber and the Role of the Cookies: solved examples

Ordered from board level to HOTS. Try each one before you open the solution.

Example 1: Why the reading · 1 mark · MCQBoard level

In Mrs Drew's scheme, the request to be read to serves mainly as:
(a) a punishment for Bubber (b) a pretext that keeps the boy sitting close to her (c) a lesson in reading (d) a reward for eating the cookies

Try it first, then show the solutionSolution
  1. The reading is the pretext for the next request, the touch (0.5).
  2. It keeps the boy sitting close so that she can touch his arm (0.5).

Answer: (b)

Example 2: Why she wanted him to keep visiting · 1 mark · Short answerBoard level

Finish the sentence with the cause: Mrs Drew wanted Bubber to keep visiting because ____

Try it first, then show the solutionSolution
  1. She drew from his vitality and enjoyed the change (0.5).
  2. She was growing younger again by stealing his youth (0.5).

Answer: she was growing younger again by stealing his youth through his visits.

Example 3: The role of the cookies (5 marks) · 5 marks · Long answerHarder board level

What is the role of the cookies in Mrs Drew's relationship with Bubber? (100-150 words)

Try it first, then show the solutionSolution
  1. The cookies are what bring Bubber to her house again and again (1.5).
  2. They are bait; the reading is the pretext and the touch the means (1.5).
  3. They show appearance and reality: a kindly act hides a sinister purpose (1).
  4. They show a child's innocence and temptation (1).

Answer: The cookies are the bait that brings Bubber back to Mrs Drew's house again and again. Once he is there, the request to be read to keeps him sitting close, and the request to touch his arm lets her draw his vitality. Thus the cookies make a harmless, kindly gesture the first step of a sinister plan. They also show how a child's appetite and politeness are used against him, while the old woman grows younger by stealing his youth.

Example 4: The last visit (5 marks) · 5 marks · Long answerHarder board level

Bubber announces that he will not be coming again. Explain Mrs Drew's reaction and what it reveals about her motives. (100-150 words)

Try it first, then show the solutionSolution
  1. Without Bubber she loses the chance to renew her youth (2).
  2. In his absence she would grow old and wrinkled again (1.5).
  3. Her shock shows dependence, not friendship (1.5).

Answer: Mrs Drew is stunned because Bubber's visits are her source of youth. Every visit lets her draw his vitality and grow younger. If he stops coming, she loses that opportunity and would grow old and wrinkled again. Her shock is therefore not the sadness of a lonely woman losing a friend, but the alarm of someone about to lose the source of her life, which reveals the exploitation under her kindness.

Example 5: Appearance and reality (10 marks) · 10 marks · Long answerHOTS / competency

'The Cookie Lady is a story in which kindness is not what it seems.' Discuss with reference to Mrs Drew's behaviour and Bubber's visits. (200-250 words)

Try it first, then show the solutionSolution
  1. The surface: an old, weak-sighted woman who bakes for a boy and asks to be read to (2).
  2. The reality: the cookies, the reading and the touch serve her purpose of drawing his youth (3).
  3. The last visit: her stun reveals her dependence and fear of old age (2).
  4. Themes: exploitation of the young by the old, temptation and innocence (2).
  5. Conclusion and expression (1).

Answer: At first Mrs Drew seems a harmless old woman who bakes for a boy and, since she does not see well, asks him to read to her. But the specimen key shows the truth: she was growing younger again by stealing his youth. The cookies are the bait that keep bringing Bubber back, the reading is the pretext that keeps him sitting close, and her request to touch his arm is the means by which she draws his vitality. The contrast between a cosy surface and a sinister purpose gives the story its chill. Her reaction to his announcement of a last visit confirms this: she is stunned, since without him she would lose the opportunity to renew her youth and would grow old and wrinkled again. This is not friendship but dependence. Bubber gains only treats, while she gains life, so the relationship is one-sided exploitation of a child's innocence and appetite. Thus kindness in the story is not what it seems.

Where students lose marks in The Cookie Lady: Mrs Drew's Fascination with Bubber and the Role of the Cookies

The slips examiners see most often, and what to write instead.

  • Mistake: Reading her as a lonely old lady only

    The story's point is the hidden motive.

    Wrong working

    Mrs Drew is a lonely woman who needs company.

    Right working

    She is drawing on Bubber's youth; the kindness hides exploitation.

    Do this: Reveal the purpose.

    Usually costs: 2-3 marks.

  • Mistake: Omitting the role of the cookies

    The specimen asked specifically about them.

    Wrong working

    Only the reading and touch described.

    Right working

    Cookies as bait, reading as pretext, touch as means.

    Do this: Use the three devices.

    Usually costs: 1.5 marks.

  • Mistake: Quoting from memory

    The text is not reproduced; wrong quotes lose marks.

    Wrong working

    Invented lines.

    Right working

    Short quotations copied from Prism, or paraphrase.

    Do this: Paraphrase if unsure.

    Usually costs: 1 mark.

Exam tips

  • The Cookie Lady has been set in both 2025 papers; expect a 5-mark answer.
  • State the hidden purpose within the first two sentences.
  • Link cookies, reading and touch to the theme of appearance and reality.
  • Keep 5-mark answers to 100-150 words.

Practice questions on The Cookie Lady: Mrs Drew's Fascination with Bubber and the Role of the Cookies

Write each answer on paper first. Open the hint only if you are stuck, and the answer only when you have finished.

  1. Q1 · 1 mark · Very short answerBoard level

    Who wrote The Cookie Lady?

    Hint

    Known for science fiction.

    Answer

    Philip K. Dick.

  2. Q2 · 5 marks · Long answerBoard level

    Why does Mrs Drew ask whether she may touch Bubber's arm, according to the specimen key?

    Hint

    Vitality.

    Answer

    She asks while he is reading, close to her. According to the specimen key she drew from his vitality and enjoyed the transformation she experienced, so the touch is the means by which she renews her youth. It shows that her interest in him is not innocent kindness but a hidden need.

  3. Q3 · 5 marks · Long answerHarder board level

    How does the story use the ideas of innocence and temptation?

    Hint

    Child and treats.

    Answer

    Bubber is a child whose appetite for cookies and politeness lead him to keep visiting and to agree to read to her and let her touch his arm. Mrs Drew uses his innocence and the small temptation of treats to take what she wants from him. He gains cookies; she gains youth. The contrast shows how easily a child can be drawn in.

  4. Q4 · 5 marks · Long answerHOTS / competency

    Do you think Mrs Drew is a sympathetic or a sinister character? Support your view. (100-150 words)

    Hint

    Fear of ageing versus exploitation.

    Answer

    She is mainly sinister. Her fear of growing old and wrinkled is understandable, but she satisfies it by exploiting a child: cookies bring him, the reading keeps him close, and her touch draws his vitality, growing younger by stealing his youth. Her shock at his last visit shows dependence on him as a source of life. Sympathy for her fear is overshadowed by the harm she does to an innocent boy.

Test your recall

Answer in your head or on paper first, then open the card. Pulling an answer out of memory makes it stick far better than re-reading.

  1. 1.What do the cookies do?Show answer

    They bring Bubber back again and again.

  2. 2.Why does she ask to be read to?Show answer

    She says she does not see well; it also keeps him close.

  3. 3.Why is she stunned at his last visit?Show answer

    She would lose her source of youth and grow old again.

  4. 4.Name a theme.Show answer

    Appearance and reality, or exploitation of the young.

The Cookie Lady: Mrs Drew's Fascination with Bubber and the Role of the Cookies: frequently asked questions

Is the story a science-fiction tale?

The author, Philip K. Dick, is best known for science fiction; the story is read as a chilling tale of exploitation.

Is Bubber aware of what is happening?

Bubber is drawn by treats and politeness; the story does not suggest he understands what is happening.

Which items were set in 2025?

The specimen paper asked about Mrs Drew's fascination with Bubber and the role of the cookies; the 2025 board paper asked why she is stunned at his last visit.