Skip to content

Prime Minister, Council of Ministers, Bureaucracy Class 11

questionbuddy.in/cbse/class-11/political-science/executive/prime-minister-council-of-ministers-coalitions-state-executive-and-bureaucracy

Political ScienceCBSE Class 11 · Executive

The Prime Minister, Council of Ministers, Coalitions and the Bureaucracy (Class 11 Political Science, Chapter 4)

Updated 17 October 2026 · Fact-checked

The Prime Minister, leader of the Lok Sabha majority, heads a Council of Ministers collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha; the Council cannot exceed 15 per cent of the House (91st Amendment). Since 1989 coalitions have reduced the PM's authority. The permanent executive (UPSC-recruited bureaucracy) is politically neutral, selected on merit and accountable to elected ministers.

Understand The Prime Minister and Council of Ministers, Coalitions, the Governor and the Permanent Executive

Why this topic matters. Collective responsibility, the PM's position and the effect of coalitions are repeated long-answer topics; the bureaucracy part adds 3-mark questions on neutrality and recruitment.

1. Making the Council. The President appoints as PM the leader with majority support in the Lok Sabha. The PM selects ministers and allocates ranks (cabinet minister, minister of State, deputy minister) and portfolios. All ministers must be MPs; a non-member must be elected within six months. The 91st Amendment (2003) limits the Council to 15 per cent of the total members of the Lok Sabha (or Assembly).

2. Collective responsibility. The Council is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha; a government that loses its confidence must resign; a no-confidence vote even against one minister leads to the resignation of the entire Council. A minister who disagrees must accept the decision or resign (cabinet solidarity).

3. Pre-eminence of the PM. The Council comes into existence only after the PM takes oath; the PM's death or resignation dissolves it, whereas a minister's exit only creates a vacancy. The PM links the Council with the President and Parliament (Nehru: the linchpin of government). Sources of power: control over the Council, leadership of the Lok Sabha, command over the bureaucracy, access to media, projection in elections and a role as national leader at international summits.

4. Coalitions. The PM's actual power depends on political conditions; with a single-party majority the PM and Council have been unassailable. Since 1989 coalition governments have meant: a growing discretionary role of the President; more consultation among partners, eroding PM authority; restrictions on choosing ministers and allotting portfolios; and policy framed by negotiation and compromise, so the PM acts more as a negotiator.

5. State executive. A similar parliamentary form. The Governor is appointed by the President on the advice of the Union government and has more discretionary powers than the President; the Chief Minister leads the majority in the Assembly.

6. The permanent executive. The bureaucracy of trained, skilled permanent employees assists ministers in formulating and implementing policies, remains politically neutral and must faithfully help implement the policies of whichever government is elected. Recruitment is by merit through the UPSC (for the Centre) and State Public Service Commissions; members have a fixed term and can be removed only after an enquiry by a Supreme Court judge. Reservation exists for SCs and STs, later extended to women, OBCs and EWS. IAS and IPS officers are appointed by the Centre, work under State supervision, and only the Centre can take disciplinary action against them, strengthening central control. Problems: insensitivity and political interference; the Right to Information is expected to improve responsiveness.

The Prime Minister and Council of Ministers, Coalitions, the Governor and the Permanent Executive: key facts

Council limits
  • Not more than 15 per cent of Lok Sabha or Assembly members
  • 91st Amendment 2003
  • Minister who is not an MP must be elected within six months
Size and membership.
Collective responsibility
  • Council responsible to Lok Sabha
  • Loss of confidence: resignation
  • One minister defeated: whole Council resigns
Cabinet solidarity.
Coalition effects
  • President's role grows
  • PM consults partners
  • Choice of ministers restricted
  • PM as negotiator
Since 1989.
Bureaucracy
  • UPSC recruits
  • Merit
  • Neutral
  • IAS/IPS appointed by Centre
  • Discipline by Centre
Permanent executive.

How to answer The Prime Minister and Council of Ministers, Coalitions, the Governor and the Permanent Executive questions

Collective-responsibility answers state the principle, the mechanism and the consequence.

  1. 1State that the Council is responsible to the Lok Sabha.
  2. 2Explain the mechanism: no-confidence motion.
  3. 3Give the consequence: resignation of the whole Council.
  4. 4Add the idea of cabinet solidarity.

The Prime Minister and Council of Ministers, Coalitions, the Governor and the Permanent Executive in real life

The idea, met in an everyday situation. Answer the question in your own words, then compare with the model answer. The one-line hook is what to remember.

Minister loses a vote

Suppose a no-confidence motion against one minister of a state cabinet is passed by the Assembly.

What happens to the Council?

Try it first, then show the solutionSolution
  1. Collective responsibility applies.
  2. The entire Council of Ministers resigns.

Answer: The whole Council resigns.

Memory hook: One falls, all fall.

New policy, same officer

Suppose a senior civil servant who helped write one government's policy faithfully drafts the changed policy of the next elected government.

Which feature of the bureaucracy is shown?

Try it first, then show the solutionSolution
  1. Political neutrality.
  2. The bureaucracy implements the policies of any elected government.

Answer: Political neutrality.

Memory hook: Serve every government.

Tricks to remember The Prime Minister and Council of Ministers, Coalitions, the Governor and the Permanent Executive

Short memory aids. Say each one aloud once, then use it on a question the same day.

  • 15 per cent

    91st Amendment cap on ministers

    Use it when: Size.

  • One falls, all fall

    Collective responsibility

    Use it when: Rule.

  • UPSC and merit

    Recruitment of civil servants

    Use it when: Bureaucracy.

The Prime Minister and Council of Ministers, Coalitions, the Governor and the Permanent Executive: solved examples

Ordered from board level to HOTS. Try each one before you open the solution.

Example 1: Cap on ministers · 1 mark · MCQBoard level

The Council of Ministers cannot exceed what share of the Lok Sabha membership after the 91st Amendment?
(A) 10 per cent
(B) 15 per cent
(C) 25 per cent
(D) 33 per cent

Try it first, then show the solutionSolution
  1. The limit is 15 per cent (1 mark).

Answer: (B)

Example 2: Permanent executive · 2 marks · Very short answerBoard level

Who forms the permanent executive and why is political neutrality important? (2 marks)

Try it first, then show the solutionSolution
  1. Civil servants who handle day-to-day administration (1 mark).
  2. They must implement the policies of any elected government faithfully (1 mark).

Answer: The permanent executive consists of civil servants responsible for day-to-day administration. Political neutrality matters because they must faithfully and efficiently implement the policies of whichever government is elected.

Example 3: Collective responsibility · 3 marks · Short answerHarder board level

Explain collective responsibility with its consequences. (3 marks)

Try it first, then show the solutionSolution
  1. Council is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha (1 mark).
  2. Loss of confidence, even against one minister, means resignation of the entire Council (1 mark).
  3. A minister who disagrees must accept the decision or resign (cabinet solidarity) (1 mark).

Answer: The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha. If the House loses confidence in the government, or passes a no-confidence vote even against one minister, the entire Council must resign. A minister who disagrees with a decision must either accept it or resign, which is called cabinet solidarity.

Example 4: Assertion and reason: PM pre-eminence · 1 mark · Assertion-reasonHarder board level

Assertion (A): The resignation of the Prime Minister dissolves the Council of Ministers.
Reason (R): The Council comes into existence only after the PM takes oath.
(A) Both true, R explains A
(B) Both true, R does not explain A
(C) A true, R false
(D) A false, R true

Try it first, then show the solutionSolution
  1. The Council exists only with the PM (1 mark).

Answer: (A)

Example 5: HOTS: size limit · 5 marks · Long answerHOTS / competency

The Lok Sabha has 543 members. Find the maximum size of the Council of Ministers under the 15 per cent rule, and for an Assembly of 200 members. Explain why the limit was introduced and how coalitions made it necessary. (5 marks)

Try it first, then show the solutionSolution
  1. 15 / 100 x 543 = 81.45, so at most 81 ministers (1 mark).
  2. 15 / 100 x 200 = 30 ministers (1 mark).
  3. Before the 91st Amendment there was no limit and councils became very large (1 mark).
  4. Large councils were partly used to win support in hung legislatures and coalitions (1 mark).
  5. The limit restricts such expansion and keeps the executive manageable (1 mark).

Answer: The maximum size is 15 per cent of 543 = 81.45, so at most 81 ministers (the figure is rounded down). For a 200-member Assembly it is 30. Before the 91st Amendment (2003) there was no limit and councils grew very large, partly to win support in hung legislatures and coalition arrangements. The cap restricts this kind of expansion and keeps the executive manageable.

Where students lose marks in The Prime Minister and Council of Ministers, Coalitions, the Governor and the Permanent Executive

The slips examiners see most often, and what to write instead.

  • Mistake: Saying the Council is responsible to the President

    Formal head confusion.

    Wrong working

    Council is responsible to the President.

    Right working

    Council is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha.

    Do this: Name the Lok Sabha.

    Usually costs: 1 mark.

  • Mistake: Writing the Council cap as 10 per cent

    Number slip.

    Wrong working

    10 per cent.

    Right working

    15 per cent (91st Amendment).

    Do this: Learn 15.

    Usually costs: 1 mark.

  • Mistake: Saying civil servants are elected

    Mix with ministers.

    Wrong working

    Civil servants are elected representatives.

    Right working

    Civil servants are permanent, recruited on merit.

    Do this: Contrast with ministers.

    Usually costs: 1 mark.

Exam tips

  • Define collective responsibility in one sentence and give its consequence.
  • Quote the 91st Amendment and the 15 per cent cap.
  • List four effects of coalitions.

Practice questions on The Prime Minister and Council of Ministers, Coalitions, the Governor and the Permanent Executive

Write each answer on paper first. Open the hint only if you are stuck, and the answer only when you have finished.

  1. Q1 · 1 mark · MCQBoard level

    The Union Public Service Commission recruits:
    (A) ministers
    (B) civil servants for the Government of India
    (C) judges
    (D) Governors

    Hint

    Merit.

    Answer

    (B)

  2. Q2 · 2 marks · Very short answerBoard level

    State two sources of the Prime Minister's power. (2 marks)

    Hint

    Council, Lok Sabha.

    Answer

    Control over the Council of Ministers and leadership of the Lok Sabha; also command over the bureaucracy, access to media and role as national leader at international forums.

  3. Q3 · 3 marks · Short answerHarder board level

    In a coalition government a Prime Minister cannot freely choose ministers or policies. Explain this with three effects of coalitions noted in the chapter. (3 marks)

    Hint

    Negotiator.

    Answer

    Coalition governments have increased the President's discretionary role in selecting PMs, increased consultation with partners that erodes the PM's authority, restricted the PM's choice of ministers and portfolios, and made policy a matter of negotiation, so the PM acts more as a negotiator than a leader.

  4. Q4 · 3 marks · Short answerHarder board level

    Distinguish the Governor from the President in appointment and discretion. (3 marks)

    Hint

    Appointed, discretion.

    Answer

    The President is elected indirectly by MPs and MLAs, while the Governor is appointed by the President on the advice of the Union government. The Governor has more discretionary powers than the President.

  5. Q5 · 4 marks · Short answerHOTS / competency

    A group says "civil servants must follow every instruction of ministers, including illegal ones, since ministers are elected". Using the chapter, evaluate the claim and note what safeguards and problems exist. (4 marks)

    Hint

    Neutral but accountable.

    Answer

    Elected ministers control the administration and officers cannot act against the legislature's policies, but civil servants are also recruited on merit by the UPSC, have a degree of security and must not become instruments of politicians; too much political interference is a problem. Accountability to citizens, through devices like the Right to Information, is also needed, so blind obedience is not what the chapter supports.

Test your recall

Answer in your head or on paper first, then open the card. Pulling an answer out of memory makes it stick far better than re-reading.

  1. 1.Who is the linchpin of government?Show answer

    The Prime Minister.

  2. 2.Which Commission recruits civil servants?Show answer

    The UPSC.

  3. 3.How long can a non-MP minister serve?Show answer

    Six months unless elected.

  4. 4.Who appoints the Governor?Show answer

    The President on the advice of the Union government.

The Prime Minister and Council of Ministers, Coalitions, the Governor and the Permanent Executive: frequently asked questions

What is cabinet solidarity?

Ministers must accept collective decisions or resign.

Who can take action against IAS officers?

Only the Centre.

Which reservation applies in the services?

SCs and STs, later women, OBCs and EWS.